How to Treat Acne Scars

Microneedle RF vs Ablative Laser: How They Differ for Acne Scars

Microneedle RF and ablative laser (CO2, Er:YAG) do different jobs: one helps volume, the other works scar edges. Which scars suit each, and the PIH risk, by Dr. Big.

Comparison of a microneedle RF device and an ablative laser, cream editorial

Quick answer: Microneedle RF and ablative laser do not replace each other, because they address different problems. Microneedle RF mainly helps volume under the skin and suits rolling scars without fibrous bands. Ablative laser (Er:YAG, CO2) works on steep scar edges. Microneedle RF does not change the steepness of the edge and does not cut fibrous bands, so deep scars often need ablative laser together with subcision and TCA CROSS, according to the doctor’s assessment.

“Which is better, microneedle RF or ablative laser (CO2/Er:YAG)?”

I hear this question often, but these two devices work by different mechanisms, address different problems, and carry different risks. The question to ask first is what your scars are stuck on.

In this article I compare the two and say which kind of scar each suits.

How they work: what is different

Microneedle RF (Microneedle Radiofrequency)

Ablative Fractional Laser (CO2 / Er:YAG)

Microneedle RF = heat under the skin through needles. Ablative = removing and burning the skin from the top.

Comparison table

FactorMicroneedle RFAblative Fractional Laser
MechanismRF energy in the needlesLaser burns the skin
Main jobVolume under the skinTexture and scar edges
Depth0.5-3.5 mm (adjustable, with care near the fat layer)0.3-2 mm (depends on wavelength)
SuitsRolling scars without fibrous bandsBoxcar scars, steep edges, deep scars
Does not fixSteep edges, fibrous bands, very narrow ice pick scarsFibrous bands, very narrow ice pick scars
PIH riskLowerHigher in Asian skin, energy must be controlled
Sessions3-5 sessions, 4-6 weeks apart2-4 sessions, 8-12 weeks apart
PainModerate (needs numbing)Moderate to high (needs numbing)

The number of sessions is a general guide. It really depends on the scars and the doctor’s assessment.

Microneedle RF: strengths and weaknesses

Strengths

Weaknesses

Ablative Fractional Laser: strengths and weaknesses

Strengths

Weaknesses

Who suits microneedle RF better

  1. Rolling scars without fibrous bands, where the main problem is volume
  2. Cases that are not severe. Microneedle RF together with pico laser may be enough
  3. Skin with a high PIH risk that needs to avoid peeling

Who suits ablative laser better

  1. Boxcar scars or scars with steep edges. They show clearly because the steep edge casts a shadow
  2. The scar does not become shallower when you stretch the cheek (Skin Stretching Test). The problem is usually the steep edge, and the rim of the scar needs to be ground down
  3. You have had microneedle RF and the scars are still not shallower
  4. You want to refine texture over the whole face

What we use at Clarity

I start by reading the scars before choosing a device: the type, the depth, whether there are fibrous bands, and whether it is a texture or a volume problem.

See Acne scar lasers: the different types, How deep scars are treated, and Acne mark lasers: the different types

Combining them: the order within one session

Before treatment I examine the scars and do a 3D face scan before planning, apply numbing cream, and then work in this order, which cannot be swapped.

  1. TCA CROSS goes first, because if the skin swells I can no longer see the bottom of the scar
  2. Er:YAG full beam to work on the scar edges, done before subcision for the same reason
  3. Subcision with an 18G cannula + tumescent
  4. CO2 after the fibrous bands are released, because I want the most contraction (my intention based on what I have observed, not a research finding)
  5. Shallow fractional Er:YAG across the whole area to stimulate new skin formation

This set is chosen for each person’s scars. Not everyone needs every step.

Frequently asked questions

Q: Can PIH happen after microneedle RF? A: It can, but the risk is usually lower than with ablative, and most cases come from not wearing sunscreen after treatment.

Q: Will ablative CO2 make my skin look older? A: Not if the doctor controls the energy well. If the energy is too high, the skin can become thin and age faster.

Q: Can I have microneedle RF while I have inflamed acne? A: You should not. Wait until the acne has calmed down (4-6 weeks).

Q: Can I have microneedle RF and subcision on the same day? A: Yes, in cases where the doctor judges it suitable. Subcision addresses only the fibrous bands, while microneedle RF helps volume, and I rarely do subcision alone. Read the reasons in What is subcision

Q: Where can I get advice near BTS on microneedle RF or ablative laser? A: At Clarity Clinic Ratchathewi, a 1-minute walk from BTS Ratchathewi, easy to reach from Siam, Phaya Thai, and all over Bangkok. Dr. Big assesses and treats you himself, with a free 30-minute consultation.

Summary

These two devices address different problems, so I choose according to your scars. No single device does it all.

Contact:

Read next:

References

Outcomes vary by individual; this article is educational, not a substitute for in-person medical assessment.

Read the full overview: Acne scar treatment: the complete guide