Filler vs Subcision for Acne Scars — Which One, or Both Together
How filler and Subcision differ for acne scars: Subcision releases fibrous bands, filler adds volume. Which scars suit each, and the risks. Dr. Big explains, near BTS.
Quick answer: Subcision treats only the fibrous bands that pull on the scar, while filler corrects the volume under the scar directly. They fix different problems, so it is often not a choice of one or the other. If a scar has both fibrous bands and lost tissue, I do needle subcision and then place filler under the scar, adding only a little and not injecting shallowly into the skin layer.
“Is filler for acne scars better, or Subcision?”
Dr. Big hears this question every week, and the answer is not “which one is better” but “what is your scar missing?” Acne scars have three problems: texture of the top of the skin, volume under the skin, and fibrous bands. Each has to be treated for what it is.
In this article Dr. Big compares two commonly used treatments for acne scars: filler (HA filler) and Subcision.
How they work: different at the root
Subcision = cutting the “fibrous bands” that pull on the scar
Fibrous bands under the skin pull the skin into a dip. Subcision is passing an instrument under the skin and cutting those bands, so the skin that was held down is freed. It does not add back the tissue that has been lost.
Read the full article: Subcision, releasing the fibrous bands under a scar
Works on: the part that pulls
Filler = adding volume under the scar
Filler for acne scars means placing HA (hyaluronic acid) under the scar after the fibrous bands have been released, to correct the volume directly. Only a little is added, and it is not injected shallowly into the skin layer.
Works on: the missing tissue
Subcision treats the part that pulls · filler treats the missing tissue. If a scar has both problems, both have to be treated.
Comparison table
| Factor | Subcision | HA filler |
|---|---|---|
| What it does | Cuts the fibrous bands | Adds volume under the scar |
| Treats | The part that pulls | Volume |
| Does not treat | Lost tissue | Scar edges and color marks |
| How long it lasts | Without new collagen or filling to support it, the scar can sink back | 6-18 months, needs topping up |
| When you see the result | Has to wait, together with whatever is done alongside | Can be seen soon after the injection |
| Suits | Rolling scars with fibrous bands | Scars with lost volume |
| Does not suit | Ice pick scars | Ice pick scars, hypertrophic (raised) scars |
| Pain | Moderate (numbing first) | Mild (numbing) |
| Risks | Bruising, swelling, infection, lumps under the skin | Blocked blood vessels (vascular occlusion, embolism), uncommon but serious |
Which scars each works for
Subcision is used for:
- ✅ Rolling scars with fibrous bands pulling on them
- ✅ Boxcar scars that are deep and have fibrous bands, together with shaving the edges with Er:YAG or CO2
- ❌ Ice pick scars are too narrow, so use TCA CROSS instead
Filler is used for:
- ✅ Rolling scars where the tissue under the skin is reduced
- ✅ Scars that are still not shallow enough after the fibrous bands are cut
- ✅ Boxcar scars that are deep and need volume corrected
- ❌ Ice pick scars: the injection cannot reach the bottom of a narrow scar
- ❌ Hypertrophic scars, where the skin is raised and not sunken
The scar edges and color marks are a texture problem and need laser to finish.
Read more: Acne scar types: rolling, boxcar, ice pick and Rolling scars: Subcision + HA + PDLLA
HA filler for acne scars: which one
The doctor chooses the type of HA filler according to the scars and skin of each person. If a lot of volume is lost, a biostimulator may be used as well.
⚠️ Never use permanent filler (silicone, PMMA). It stays forever, and if the result is poor it is hard to correct.
Cost
Cost depends on each person’s plan. Add us on LINE @clarityclinic and ask which program suits your scars.
When filler is used together with Subcision
- The scar has fibrous bands and has lost volume as well
- The bands were cut before but the scar is still not shallow enough
In this case I use needle subcision and then place filler under the scar.
When laser is used together with Subcision
- The main problem is the scar edge and texture, together with fibrous bands
- The plan relies on the skin contracting from laser
In this case I use cannula subcision and then do CO2 after the bands are released. If a rolling scar has no fibrous bands, there is nothing to cut.
Frequently asked questions
Q: Is filler for acne scars dangerous? A: There are risks, especially blocked blood vessels. They are uncommon, but it must be done by a skilled doctor, and permanent filler (silicone) should not be used.
Q: Does filler dissolve completely after it is injected? A: HA filler slowly breaks down in the body (6-18 months). It does not stay forever like permanent filler.
Q: Does Subcision hurt more than filler? A: Both use numbing first and hurt about the same. Subcision feels like “pulling” under the skin, and filler feels like “tightness”.
Q: Can both be done on the same day? A: In some cases, yes. I do needle subcision first and then place filler under the scar. Dr. Big assesses every time.
Q: Where near BTS can I consult about whether Subcision or filler suits me? A: At Clarity Clinic Ratchathewi, near BTS Ratchathewi (a 1-minute walk), an easy trip from Siam, Phaya Thai and across Bangkok. Dr. Big assesses and treats in person. Free 30-minute consultation.
Summary
Subcision treats the part that pulls and does not add tissue. Filler adds volume under the scar, but it lasts only a period of time and does not treat the scar edges.
I almost never do Subcision on its own. If filler is used, I use needle subcision. If laser is used, I use cannula subcision, and I choose according to each person’s scars. Read more in Subcision, releasing the fibrous bands under a scar.
Contact:
- Add us on LINE @clarityclinic to send photos of your scars to Dr. Big first and ask which program suits your scars
- Location: Spring Tower, floor B · Ratchathewi, near BTS (Siam, Phaya Thai, across Bangkok)
- Free 30-minute consultation with Dr. Big in person
Read next:
- Subcision, releasing the fibrous bands under a scar
- Rolling scars: Subcision + HA + PDLLA
- Acne scar types: rolling, boxcar, ice pick
References
Outcomes vary by individual; this article is educational, not a substitute for in-person medical assessment.
- Orentreich DS, Orentreich N. Subcutaneous incisionless (subcision) surgery for the correction of depressed scars and wrinkles. Dermatol Surg. 1995. PubMed
- Jacob CI, Dover JS, Kaminer MS. Acne scarring: a classification system and review of treatment options. J Am Acad Dermatol. 2001. PubMed
- Gozali MV, Zhou B. Effective treatments of atrophic acne scars. J Clin Aesthet Dermatol. 2015. PubMed
Read the full overview: Acne scar treatment: the complete guide